This one is great and funny in a pathetic way!
The 5 Worst Plays From Industry’s Disinformation Playbook
GENNA REED, SCIENCE AND POLICY ANALYST, CENTER FOR SCIENCE AND DEMOCRACY | OCTOBER 24, 2017, 10:14 AM EST
Bookmark and Share
When I was 13, this is what I identified as the hardest thing about life then. My trust issues were just beginning to manifest themselves.
I have always had a healthy dose of curiosity and skepticism and a desire to hold people accountable for their statements built into my DNA. Usually, these were borne out in letter-writing campaigns. As a child, I sent a series of letters to the Daily News because I believed its campaign of “No More Schmutz!” was falling short after rifling through the pages and still having gray smudges on my fingers. Inky fingers is a far cry from misinformation about the dangers of fossil fuel pollution, but overall, my general pursuit for the truth hasn’t changed.
My newest project at the Center for Science and Democracy released today is a website that exposes the ways in which companies seek to hide the truth about the impacts of their products or actions on health and the environment. By calling out the plays in the “Disinformation Playbook,” we hope to ensure that powerful companies and institutions are not engaging in behavior that would obstruct the government’s ability to keep us safe, and at the very least aren’t doing us any harm. Unfortunately, as our case studies show, there are far too many examples in which companies and trade organizations have made intentional decisions to delay or obstruct science-based safeguards, putting our lives at risk.
In the Disinformation Playbook, we reveal the five tactics that some companies use to manipulate, attack, or create doubt about science and the scientists conducting important research that appears unfavorable to a company’s products or actions. We also feature twenty case studies that show how companies in a range of different industries have used these tactics in an effort to sideline science.
While not all companies engage in this irresponsible behavior, the companies and trade associations we highlight in the playbook have acted in legally questionable and ethically unsound ways. Here are five of the most egregious examples from the Playbook:
The Fake: Conducting counterfeit science
In an attempt to reduce litigation costs, Georgia-Pacific secretly ran a research program intended to raise doubts about the dangers of asbestos and stave off regulatory efforts to ban the chemical. The company used knowingly flawed methodologies in its science as well as publishing its research in scientific journals without adequately disclosing the authors’ conflicts of interest. By seeding the literature with counterfeit science, Georgia-Pacific created a life-threatening hazard by deceiving those who rely on science to understand the health risks of asbestos exposure. While asbestos use has been phased out in the US, it is not banned, and mesothelioma still claims the lives of thousands of people very year.
The Blitz: Harassing scientists
Rather than honestly dealing with its burgeoning concussion problem, the National Football League (NFL) went after the reputation of the first doctor to link the sport to the degenerative brain disease he named Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy. What Omalu found in Mike Webster’s brain—chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), a progressive degenerative disease mainly associated with “punch drunk” boxers and victims of brain trauma—broke the NFL’s burgeoning concussion problem wide open. But instead of working with scientists and doctors to better understand the damaging effect of repeated concussions and how the league could improve the game to reduce head injuries, the NFL went after the reputation of Omalu and the other scientists who subsequently worked on CTE. Just this year, Boston University scientists released a study of 111 deceased former NFL players’ brains, revealing that all but one had signs of CTE.
The Diversion: Sowing uncertainty
The top lobbyist for the fossil fuel industry in the western United States secretly ran more than a dozen front groups in an attempt to undermine forward-looking policy on climate change and clean technologies. As a leaked 2014 presentation by Western States Petroleum Association (WSPA) President Catherine Reheis-Boyd revealed, WSPA’s strategy was to use these fabricated organizations to falsely represent grassroots opposition to forward-looking policy on climate change and clean technologies. WSPA and its member companies oppose science-based climate policies that are critically needed to mitigate the damaging impacts of global warming.
The Screen: Borrowing credibility
Coca-Cola quietly funded a research institute out of the University of Colorado designed to persuade people to focus on exercise, not calorie intake, for weight loss. Emails between the company and the institute’s president suggested Coca-Cola helped pick the group’s leaders, create its mission statement, and design its website. A growing body of scientific evidence links sugar to a variety of negative health outcomes, including diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and high cholesterol. Coca-Cola’s actions overrode sensible transparency safeguards meant to ensure the independence of research—and allow consumers to understand the risks of sugar consumption for themselves.
The Fix: Manipulating government officials
After meeting with and listening to talking points from chlorpyrifos producer Dow Chemical Company, the EPA announced it would be reversing its decision to ban the chemical that is linked to neurological development issues in children. In 2016, the EPA concluded that chlorpyrifos can have harmful effects on child brain development. The regulation of chlorpyrifos is additionally an environmental justice issue. Latino children in California are 91 percent more likely than white children to attend schools near areas of heavy pesticide use.
The secret to a good defense is a good offense
By arming ourselves with independent science, we can fight back against these familiar tactics. Granted, it’s not an easy task, especially in the face of a government run by an administration that doesn’t appear to value evidence, believing asbestos is 100% safe and claiming that climate change is a hoax. I hear powerful stories every day of communities working together to crush corporate disinformation campaigns with the hard truth.
Just a couple of weeks ago, community members from Hoosick Falls, New York attended the hearing for “toxicologist-for-hire,” Dr. Michael Dourson, the nominee to head up the EPA’s Office of Chemical Safety and Pollution Prevention. Senator Kristen Gillibrand paid homage to their bravery, “The water that they drink, the water they give their children, the water they cook in, the water they bathe in, is contaminated by PFOA. These families are so frightened.” These individuals had a powerful story to tell about the way in which DuPont downplayed the dangers of the chemical byproduct of Teflon, C8 or PFOA, and Dourson’s consulting firm, hired by DuPont, recommended a far lower standard for the chemical than most scientists believe would have protected exposed residents from harm.
We hope that reading through the playbook will encourage you to stand up for science and join us as we continue to challenge companies that attempt to sideline science, seeking business as usual at our expense. Become a science champion today and take a stand against corporate disinformation by asking your members of congress not to do automakers’ bidding by rolling back valuable progress on vehicle efficiency standards.
Stay curious, stay skeptical, and together we can work toward making corporate culture more honest and transparent by raising the political cost of using the disinformation playbook.
U.S. Denies Entry to former British Ambassador Craig Murray The U.S. government, for no stated reason, and after having approved his entry in the past, has denied Craig Murray the Continue Reading →
Hint: when you stop at a gas station, the grossest thing may not be the bathroom. By Larry Schwartz / AlterNet Photo Credit: Phovoir / Shutterstock America is a gas-guzzling, Continue Reading →
RT America has uploaded ‘CALEXIT’ 2018: Ballot measure calling for secession presented to state AG ‘CALEXIT’ 2018: Ballot measure calling for secession presented to s… RT America A ballot measure Continue Reading →
Energy from wind, water and sun would eliminate nuclear and fossil fuels
By Mark Fischetti | November 19, 2015
DOCUMENTING FOSSIL FUEL COMPANIES’ CLIMATE DECEPTION Jul 15, 2015 by Casey Coates Danson [Translate] Catalyst Summer 2015 Climate denier dossiers Leaked internal memos reveal a coordinated, decades-long disinformation campaign. by Continue Reading →
LEARNING SOME LIFE LESSONS: Grief By William Olkowski 6.2.12/7.25.12 Well this morning I am going to take on my current main daily subject: grief. The take will be conceptual rather Continue Reading →
CONSIDER THE ANT AND BE WISE by William Olkowski republished again today 11.21.14 previously 2.1.12 “Consider the Ant” is good advice. After all, as social experiments go, ant colony life Continue Reading →
BRAVE NEW WORLD ON THE WAY THE POPULATION PROBLEM REDUX by William Olkowski, PhD 10.25.12 Globally, assisted reproductive techniques result in 350,000 babies a year, research shows. 5 million artificial Continue Reading →
THE GMO HEALTH DEBATE: War of the Blogs by William Olkowski, PhD. 10.1.12 This so called GMO health debate is shaping up to be another David and Goliath Story, with Continue Reading →
Does the Mayan Calendar Predict the End of the World? By William Olkowski, PhD. 9.22.12 I heard the Spindrift broadcast, on Thursday 9:30 am to 10:00 on 91.9 FM, and Continue Reading →
PAST, FUTURE AND TODAY A Musing to Self. By William Olkowski, PhD, 7.15.12. Apologies to Omar Khayyam but … this is how I remember the quote: “Dead yesterday, unborn tomorrow, Continue Reading →
HOMOPHOBIA AND THE BOY SCOUTS OFAMERICA By William Olkowski, posted 9.14.12 The Boy Scouts of America has reaffirmed its exclusion of known homosexual men from membership and as volunteer teachers. Continue Reading →
WHAT CAN WE LEARN FROM THE WEST NILE VIRUS SITUATION? By William Olkowski, PhD. 9.14.12 Part of this report was aired on 91.9 FM, KCFM, on the University of Santa Continue Reading →
Notes for a radio broadcast on 91.9FM, KCSB, 9.13.12, program Spindrift, 9:30 am PST. WELCOME AND INTRODUCTION BY Marika Davidek and William Olkowski, PhD. 9.13.12 Announcements This quote is by Continue Reading →
94 FOLD INCREASE IN GMO CROPS in US from 1996-2011. Crops include: soy, corn, cotton, canola, sugar beets (main source of sugar), squash, alfalfa (main source for meats and milk), and Continue Reading →
By Wm Olkowski, PhD, republished from 10.24.11 Dear Governor Brown, Re: Pest Control and Pesticide Use I thought of writing you to reacquaint about a project your previous administration funded Continue Reading →